«Home

Was Prophet Mohamed A Book Pirate ?

I read the quran and some of my abservations is that some things and names mentioned  in the Holy Bible which were told and written many centuries before mohamed was born are found in his qu ran,

did he Pirate the Bible or atleast part of the bible to manufacture his qu ran, was he a Pirate ?

Avatar
Newbie
18 answers

Let me ask a simple questn. Which d holy books is false?is it d bible that was written btwn 500yrs by dif people yet sayin same thing or d koran writen by one single man in a cave. Which of these books cld b authentic. Ur answer is as good as mine.evidently,d koran plagerizd d bible(breaking copyrite laws) yet making fundamental errors. For more details about d flaws in the koran check www.islamlies.com.

0
Avatar
Newbie

@Tudor, if anybody on this thread will later revert to Islam, i believe if u will not be the #1, you will be among the first 3 or 5 considering your level of assimilation and your mentality. What you need do is to just try to do away with the vices you call virtues especially any form of atrocities which you might be engaged with. I'm not accusing you though but remember i can't judge myself to be the best except if i wanna be a local champion. Please, whenever you read these books(Bible & Qur'an), don't be sentimental, rather seek divine intervention.(all thses will be baseless if you are rock-hearted about your faith).

@Sleek29, didn't Jesus say nobody has ever heard God's voice?"And the Father himself, which hath sent me, hath borne witness of me. Ye have neither heard his voice at any time, nor seen his shape. " (John 5:37).

0
Avatar
Newbie

http://www.bible.ca/islam/islam-myths-embryology.htm, its not only the bible he pirated but even scientific writings which were written 450years before he was born,which makes the quran part hippocrates, part aristotle, part bible e.t.c, the bible has different accounts given by different people at different times and they all said the same thing and mine you mohammed claimed to have heard God speak to him, he alone heard it, no one else, there were people present when Jesus was baptised, they heard the voice from heaven,John heard it, the disciples were 12, 11 of them saw him, other people saw him,its easier for me to believe that because its different accounts, but mohammed was the only one in the cave.

0
Avatar
Newbie

Alhaji,

the church I speak of is different, TSC on broadway & 51st.

Plagiarism does not necessarily mean you copy the entire thing . . . it can also be parts. And you're still doing circles around your scenario - see my first response cos it appears you didn't get it the first time around.

0
Avatar
Newbie

na wa o,why he come be say na only bad bad thing people dey take remember this prophet mohammed?una sure say this man na real prophet of God abi na jeko jeko prophet chop and clean mouth prophet

0
Avatar
Newbie

@JeSoul: My college roommate Rev. David Kayode is one of the Pastors, if its the Baptist Church in Times Square you are talking about. His wife is a woman I know since they started their relationship way back them.

Now if your idea of plagiarization is to stick on Quran, then you have to show me Surah Waqiah in the Bible. Or show me Ruth, Ester, Acts of Apostles, Epistles and Revelations in the Quran. You have to show me songs of David, too.

Let me return to Quran; Show me Surah Taha, Hud, Kahf, Ya Sin, Rahman, Muhammad, Qamar, Quyamma, Fajr, Takathur, Kafiruun, Dhuha, Qadr, Balad, Talaq, Mulk, Ala, Qalaq, Abasa, etc. Show me the last three Chapters? When you look through Quran, it has nothing about the Bible, except counter points. It is a powerful thing that you made such an accusation. But where is the basis for it?

Your parents will write an accurate book about your early life. Your sister's friend acquittance will write a less accurate book, becaus he heard your sister friend said that he/she jotted down some points from your parents book, when your sister was reading it to her over the phone. Your sister express how much you were loved, but she did not read the whole book to her friend, who noted the essence of what your sister read.

The friend acquittance then took this points and ran with it, creating a book that she dubbed your life history.

Who is correct between your parents book and your sister's friend acquittance book?

The Quran is similar to what is from your parents. The Bible is what is similar to your sister's friend acquittance book. The Quran is from Alah the Speaker. The Bible, is part God, part angels, part prophets, part followers of prophets, part followers or generation that followed the followers of prophets. Paul happened to be the example I chose to show the followers of the follower of the prophets!

0
Avatar
Newbie

@Banom, for the sake of argument, Illiterate Muhammad(SAW) wrote the Qur'an, yet not only did it talk about the past, it talked about the present and the future. Now, look at the book written by some group of supposed literates, what is the difference between their books? Whose book is strictly followed till date? Whose book is divinely guarded? Whose book is most widely confirmed to br correct without revisions? Please dear, stop being bias or sentimental, many scholars have eulogized this Man called Muhammad(SAW). He's no other but a messenger of Allah. He did not fight for supremacy neither did we accord him with any. Sit again and have a re-think, ins't Muhammad a true Messenger of Allah? Please try to read thoroughly about this man and you will give your verdict.

0
Avatar
Newbie

@JeSoul: « #5 on: Today at 02:29:17 PM »

And I did not tell him that the older book was the Bible; Torah, Sabur, and Injil plus what the others wrote from Acts all the way to epistles and revelations. And I did not tell him the newer Book is simly the Quran. Think about it, JeSoul. I know you have a good mind. But old tradition passed on, generation to generation dies very slowly. Just imagine you find in Philadelphia now. You know the Germantown section is now a vibrant muslim community. All of them not because of marriage to some foreign muslims. Islam has arrived in America. No one can hide it again.

Barackallah Hussaine Obama is the occupier of the Whiet House. I know he is not a muslim. But Islamic name is forever registered on the Log of American Presidency.

0
Avatar
Newbie

@JeSoul: Let say for te sake of argument that you are an Igbo woman. Forget everything else for now, regardless of your true ethnic identity. If a man wrote a book about the origin of the igbos. And the dates and the events of the founding "fahers" so to speak were badly presented, barring te names, etc. If a later generation writer came along and wrote a more comprehensive textbook about the origins of the Igbo peoples and all the two books have in commons were the names of he main characters for the most part, but details and event dates are somethings that separate them. Can we then after critical literal analysis of these two books claim that just because the one that was earlier written was copied extensively by the more precison and scholarly superior younger book?

Even if they were written in different languages, and styles and the younger book author never had gone to the Igbo land and his book was not specific to igbo people and igbo character's alone? Could anyone not marvel at the complete contrast, and divergence of these books, speifically the accuracy of details which are verifiable in the new book, should mark it as a better grade than the old empty of substance older book? No? You are a literalist, you should know better. You are a scientist, tell me where the Bible says that the Body of Pharaoh will be preserved as a sign to later generations about the end of evil doers? I a Quranic verse that says this and it has been proven that salt was found in the lungs of a particular Pharaoh. tell me how salt gets to lungs except by drwoning in salty water; Sea, in this case Red Sea?

While the Christians argue that the Pharaoh did not die in the sea along with his army, some Christians today are say that he died. Yet Muhammad (AS) whom you claim to have plagiarized the Bible, sad over 1400 years ago that he died. Now why are the Christians just catchingu to his claim? Can we truly say he plagiarized? Absolutely not?

Ans the periodic table is now more tan 107 elements, which was the satndard in my days. Can we now say that the new Periodic table containing 112 element plagiarized the 107 periodic table? No. We can say that the one with 112 is comprehensive and alot accurate.  It is the current hallmark of what is accepted as periodic table. If the name was not accurate, the one with 112 would change it. If any element in 107 is wrong the 112 would change it and give the correct name.

0
Avatar
Newbie

Nezan, now you hate the truth. What a selfish interest

0
Avatar
Newbie

The quaran was compiled 300 years after his death too.

Piracy isn't about writing only, stealing ideas and concepts also constitute piracy.

0
Avatar
Newbie

Bros, Jesus did not write or compile the bible, the bible was compiled by the catholic church over three hundred years after his accension so it would be very naive of you to accuse him of piracy.

0
Avatar
Newbie

There's nothing new. the same way jesus' new movement of christianity pirated the old testament, so did mohammeds and his followers adopt the same OT.

The original fabricators of the old testament where the JEWS, and till today they don't recognise the authenticity of the charlatans jesus and mohammed. Jesus and mohammed simply decided to add their own remix.

So YES, mohammed was a pirate and so WAS JESUS.

0
Avatar
Newbie

@banom, had it been the Quran is from other than Allah there would have been thousand discrepancy like the bible which i have been revealing

0
Avatar
Newbie

Thanks for your informed reply, Abuzola.

0
Avatar
Newbie

How do we know it was the same God and that he truely permited Pirate mohamed ?

0
Avatar
Newbie

No, the God that revealed to moses the Torah what was written and revealed to Abraham, Ishmael, isaac, Noah, Enoch etc in the Torah was the same God that revealed it to Muhammad. Mind you, Jesus did not reveal the old testament, the christian stole it from the jews, the new testament is the one we know of jesus.

0
Avatar
Newbie

I guess he did a traditional remix.

0
Avatar
Newbie
Your answer
Add image

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.